5 Things to Do When Your Confidence Fails as a Faith-Driven Leader

Andrea Olson • April 30, 2025

5 Things to Do When Your Confidence Fails as a Faith-Driven Leader


Facing the Confidence Crisis in 2025


Let’s be real—leaders today are facing a confidence crisis.


Between the whiplash of the last six years—global pandemics, economic instability, rapid tech shifts, AI overload, and social media unpredictability—it’s easy to feel like nothing we do really sticks. If you’ve ever felt like you're just noise in the chaos, wondering whether your leadership still matters, you’re not alone.


And if you’ve found yourself saying, “I’m trying so hard, but it feels like I keep failing,” we want you to know: failure is not the end. In fact, it might be your beginning.


At Overflow Worship, we believe leadership is worship in action. And what we do on the hard days often matters more than what we do on the easy ones. So let’s talk about how to rebuild when your confidence takes a hit.

1. Slow Down and Remember the Truth


Let’s challenge the old saying, “When the going gets tough, the tough get going.”


In reality, wise leaders don’t just push through. They pause.


Think about a car chase in a movie—chaos, destruction, zero clarity. That’s what leadership can feel like when we spiral in stress. But God says, “Come to me… and I will give you rest.” (Matthew 11:28)


When you slow down and reflect on truth—God’s truth—you gain clarity. Your feelings are real, but they’re not always true. The way forward begins with a breath, a prayer, and a pause.


2. Be Kind to Yourself


Self-leadership starts with self-compassion.


We often analyze our failures in hopes of getting better, which is wise. But if that analysis turns into self-berating, we stall our progress. God doesn’t call you to beat yourself up. He calls you to examine yourself, learn, and move forward with grace.

Yes, be honest. But also be kind.


3. Measure Backwards, Not Just Forwards


One of the best ways to rebuild confidence is to measure backwards. This concept, from The Gap and the Gain by Dan Sullivan, reminds us to focus on how far we've come—not just how far we have to go.


Even if your last project flopped, think about your first. Think about how far you've grown since then. Measuring progress based on your starting point encourages growth and keeps you grounded in gratitude, not shame.


4. Hold the Right People Accountable


Let’s talk accountability. In faith-based leadership, we sometimes confuse kindness with passivity. But holding your team accountable isn’t unkind—it’s necessary.


Clear expectations create clarity, and clarity builds confidence. Whether it’s a product launch, an event, or a team project, accountability helps everyone grow. Celebrate the wins, but also acknowledge what didn’t work.


When failure happens (because it will), owning it together as a team builds trust and strengthens your leadership culture.


5. Move Forward With Surrender, Not Shame


This might be the hardest step of all.


Moving forward means letting go—not just of the failure, but of the false belief that success is the only sign of God’s favor. Sometimes, failure is God’s favor. Sometimes, unanswered prayers are His greatest answers.


If you prayed for God’s will, then trust that even the hard pivot, the closed door, or the dry season is part of His plan.

Your leadership matters. Not just when things are thriving—but especially when you're rebuilding. Failure isn’t a signal to quit. It’s an invitation to lead with deeper faith.


The Future Depends on Faith-Driven Leaders Like You


Now more than ever, the world needs business owners, entrepreneurs, and everyday leaders who live with conviction and lead from a foundation of faith. The enemy wants to discourage and disqualify you—but God’s not finished. He’s just getting started.


So here’s your reminder:

Keep going.

Keep showing up.

Keep leading from the overflow.


Want Encouragement Like This Every Week?


We believe you weren’t meant to lead alone. That’s why we created the Overflow Worship Newsletter—a free weekly resource filled with encouragement, leadership tools, and strategic systems for your life and calling.


🎯 Practical tools

📖 Biblical truth

💡 Bold encouragement

Join our newsletter today and take your next step in faith-driven leadership.


Let’s build something that lasts—together.

By Andrea Olson April 30, 2025
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Overflow Worship | www.overflowworship.com Overflow Worship is proud to announce the release of its brand-new original Christmas comedy series, “The Church” —a three-part, mockumentary-style show that takes a hilarious and heartfelt look behind the curtain of church ministry during the busiest time of the year. Created in the spirit of shows like The Office , The Church brings the camera into the week-to-week chaos of a local church staff as they prepare for their biggest event of the year: the Christmas Eve service. But behind the funny moments, awkward team dynamics, and questionable gift exchanges lies a deeper message—one that points back to the simplicity and power of the gospel at Christmas. "It’s easy to get caught up in production, planning, and trying to please everyone—especially at Christmas,” said the Overflow Worship team. “This series is a humorous reminder that in the middle of all the chaos, we’re called to keep the main thing the main thing—Jesus." 🧑‍🎄 The Office Meets Worship Ministry The story follows Ben , a new worship leader hired to bring fresh energy and modern ideas to a tradition-rich church. As he tries to balance choir expectations, budget limitations, and a tech director with strong opinions about fog machines and pre-recorded tracks, Ben quickly learns that fitting in—and standing firm—are equally challenging. Every character in The Church is exaggerated just enough to feel familiar to anyone who's served on a church team. From the high-strung event coordinator to the no-nonsense secretary to the busy tech director with too many opinions, the staff is full of heart, dysfunction, and a desire to do something meaningful. 🙏 Featuring Brian Tabor of Worship Probs One of the many Easter eggs in the series is the appearance of Pastor Greg , played by Brian Tabor , the real-life host of the popular Christian podcast Worship Probs . Known for his hilarious “Prayer Concerns” segment, Brian brings his signature dry humor and leadership insight to the role. In fact, the show goes a step further—integrating actual Worship Probs content. Every comment card read aloud in the team meetings is real —submitted by actual church attendees and previously shared on the Worship Probs podcast . These moments give the show an added layer of authenticity and relatability, especially for church leaders who’ve read a few wild cards themselves. ❄️ A Christmas Story That Feels All Too Real From glitter-covered classrooms and snow machines gone rogue to the operatic soloist who insists on singing " Mary Did You Know" (again), The Church explores the humorous tension between honoring tradition and making space for something new. Viewers will resonate with the real ministry dynamics: The pressure to impress while staying focused on Jesus The struggle to introduce innovation without alienating the congregation The behind-the-scenes exhaustion of staff trying to “make Christmas perfect” The relationships that are messy, but rooted in genuine love for the Church It all builds to a final Christmas Eve service that, despite the hiccups, captures what matters most: hope, worship, community, and the simple truth that Jesus came for us . 🎁 A Gift to Worship Teams Everywhere The Church isn’t just for laughs—it’s a celebration of church staff and volunteers who give everything they have to serve during the Christmas season.  The series is meant to affirm the unseen work of ministry teams and remind them that in the middle of all the noise, Jesus is still at the center. Whether you’re a worship leader, tech volunteer, kids director, or coffee team hero, The Church was made for you. 🎬 Watch the Full Series Now Watch all three episodes of The Church now on Overflow Worship’s official YouTube channel: 👉 youtube.com/@overflowworshipofficial Make sure to like, comment, and share —especially with your church staff, worship team, or anyone who needs a laugh and a reminder that they’re not alone.
By Andrea Olson April 16, 2025
Leading with Conviction in a Culture Full of Opinions Let’s be honest—our world is filled with strong opinions. Especially when it comes to the intersection of faith and culture, there’s no shortage of heated conversations. But for Christian leaders—whether you're in ministry, business, parenting, or everyday life—the real challenge isn’t about choosing sides. It’s about learning to lead from conviction rather than pressure. In this video, we explore some of today’s most talked-about cultural topics: the Easter Bunny, Taylor Swift, Halloween, modesty, and the movie Wicked . At first glance, it might seem like a random list, but here’s the thread—they all invite us to consider how we’re leading, what we’re consuming, and how we’re influencing others.
By Andrea Olson April 16, 2025
For many Christian business owners, integrating faith into the workplace can feel complicated. There’s a tension between being professional and being authentic, between keeping the peace and speaking truth. But the reality is, for kingdom-minded leaders, business is ministry. The two are not separate. This conversation dives into what it means to lead as a Christian in business, how to overcome common misconceptions, and how to practically build a business that reflects your faith without compromise. The Church vs. Business: Two Sides of the Same Coin The church has historically funneled leadership potential straight into ministry. If someone is a strong communicator or shows natural leadership abilities, the assumption is often that they should become a pastor. But what if those same giftings are equally (or even more) impactful in the marketplace? In ministry, relationships often need a bridge—a way to connect people to Jesus. But in business, especially when you're working side by side with clients, staff, and customers daily, the bridge isn't always needed. You’re already doing life with people. You're in close proximity with individuals who may never set foot in a church, which means you have a powerful opportunity to be the church in action. 
By Andrea Olson April 15, 2025
Why Faith-Driven Leadership Matters More Than Ever 

If you would like regular emails and updates from Overflow Worship, join the newsletter below!